Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

I’ve professed my un-love for pumpkin pie before. I just…I just don’t love it. I wouldn’t necessarily consider myself a hater. It’s just not something I crave. But I was determined to give you a pumpkin pie something this holiday season. And I think you’ll enjoy this. I did. And from a pumpkin pie un-lover, that speaks highly of this dessert.

Actually, if you were paying attention, you already had a sneak preview of this pumpkin pie sheet cake. I included it in my step-by-step Thanksgiving plan last week and a few of you picked up on that and deserve Mel’s Kitchen Reader of the Year for actually reading the fine details of what I blab about on here instead of just skimming. You are awesome. All two of you that noticed.

Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

There really aren’t any secrets or shockers with this recipe. In fact, I think the smooth, creamy pumpkin topping is almost exactly like traditional pumpkin pie filling from the back of that famous Libby’s can. The difference is that the crust on this sheet cake is a thicker layer than traditional pie crust and is buttery and cakey and totally delicious. And of course because it is a sheet cake, it’s made in a 9X13-inch pan instead of a pie plate.

Anyway, these little pumpkin pie bars are awesome. Love, love, love them. I think it has a lot to do with the crust to filling ratio matching up a little better than the wimpy, thin pie crust in the original pumpkin pie. If you just can’t break away from classic pumpkin pie, that’s ok. While you are eating your slice, I’ll be devouring my bar(s).

*Click HERE if you haven’t entered the artisan pizza oven giveaway yet!*

*Also, winners of the Gluten Free on a Shoestring Cookbook have been announced HERE.*

Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

One Year Ago: Brownie Batter Truffles
Two Years Ago: Vegetable Sauté with Simple Cream Sauce
Three Years Ago: Mississippi Mud Cake

Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

Yield: Serves 12

Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

Ingredients

    Crust:
  • 2/3 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 8 tablespoons butter (1 stick), melted
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1 large egg
  • Filling:
  • 2 large eggs
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1/4 teaspoon ginger
  • 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
  • 1/8 teaspoon cloves
  • 1 (15-ounce) can pumpkin
  • 1 (12-ounce) can evaporated milk (or 1 cup cream)
  • Sweetened whipped cream for serving

Directions

  1. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Place an oven rack in the middle of the oven (too low and the crust will burn).
  2. For the crust, whisk together the sugar, flour, baking powder and salt. Pour in the melted butter, vanilla and egg. Stir to combine (I use my hands at the end to combine the dough into a cohesive ball).
  3. Press the dough into the bottom of a lightly greased 9X13-inch pan.
  4. For the filling, you can use the same bowl that was used for the crust as long as there aren’t any large clumps of dough remaining in it. Whisk the eggs until light and creamy. Stir in the sugar, salt, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves and pumpkin. Whisk to combine. Stir in the evaporated milk or cream.
  5. Pour the filling over the crust.
  6. Bake for 35-45 minutes or until a knife inserted into the middle comes out clean. Don't overbake or the crust will be too tough.
  7. Cool completely. Cut into squares and serve with sweetened whipped cream.
http://www.melskitchencafe.com/pumpkin-pie-sheet-cake/

Recipe Source: adapted from Jamie Cooks It Up (sized it down from an enormous sheet cake to a 9X13-inch pan, used a homemade crust instead of a cake mix, etc.)

43 Responses to Pumpkin Pie Sheet Cake

  1. I feel as you do about pumpkin pie, so I most likely will love these as well. Thanks!

  2. Alex G. says:

    Love pie, love cake, love you!

  3. This would totally make me happy over pumpkin pie any day. I love simplicity.

  4. Karly says:

    I used to unlove pumpkin too. Not sure what changed, but I can eat the crap outta some pumpkin pie! Love this sheet cake!

  5. Pumpkin Pie is something I’ve only come to love in the past few years. But…I think I could love this cake instead.

  6. bluebaker says:

    Treats like this are so much easier for large groups, or to take to a church dinner.
    I’m going to work this into the menu plan here in the next few weeks. Thanks Mel.

  7. gigi says:

    I’m not a pumpkin pie fan either but I did make the pumpkin pull apart cinnamon bread last year and devoured it the majority of it in two days ha ha. This looks like a delish alternative to pie!

  8. Chantel F says:

    I am not a pumpkin pie lover at all. It’s just…weird! I actually hadn’t even tasted it until I was married! HA! I guess pumpkin pie isn’t made in Iraq, or else my dad definitely would have made it haha. But these do look pretty darn delicious! Perhaps these will be the desert I make next week!’ Thanks Mel, you just plain rock.

  9. Teresa R. says:

    Actually, I love pumpkin pie for breakfast. I think this recipe looks delicious and I can’t wait to have it for breakfast, lunch and dinner!

  10. Say whaaaaaat?! This looks awesome!

  11. Amy V says:

    Wouldn’t you know…I just signed up to make “Pumpkin Bars” for my preschooler’s Thanksgiving Feast next week! Guess what I’m going to be making?!

  12. I love easy peasy sheet cakes, especially amid the holiday rush. This looks so good, Mel!

  13. Kim in MD says:

    I have never been a fan of pumpkin pie, but I love pumpkin cake. I think I will love this cake, and I know my family will, too!

  14. kim says:

    that whipped cream on top is perfection. looks delicious!

    i’m giving away a kitchenaid mixer on my blog! i’d love it if you came by and said hi!:
    http://lovintheoven.com/2013/11/dulce-de-leche-espresso-bean-cookies.html

  15. Terri says:

    I’m making this tomorrow I cant wait! Wondering how it will be if I just double the recipe, see if I make something for my work I have to make something for my husbands also. LOL This looks fast, easy and good!

    • Mel says:

      Terri – apparently the recipe doubles great for a large 12X18-inch rimmed baking sheet if you want to try it (I haven’t but the original recipe was for that size).

  16. Jess says:

    What a great idea – I’m not a huge fan of pie of any sort, although I seriously love the pumpkin pie filling. This might be the perfect Thanksgiving dessert for me – yum!

  17. Do you think I could still make this in a jelly roll pan with your recipe? Kinda need mine to feed a crowd. Thanks!

  18. Katie says:

    I feel similarly about baked pumpkin, but LOVE our family recipe for pumpkin chiffon pie. It’s divine and I look forward to thanksgiving as the one time per year that we get it. You should try it. So yummy!

  19. Andrea says:

    I’ve been looking for an alternative to pumpkin pie and this looks better than any other recipe I’ve found. Does the crust get soggy the next day? If I make it for Thanksgiving, I’d like to bake it the day before? Thank you!

    • Mel says:

      Andrea – we had leftovers for a few days and while the crust softens a bit, I actually loved it the day after (it doesn’t get soggy, just a bit softer).

  20. CAH says:

    Oh my, this looks wonderful!

    I adore pumpkin pie, and I have a fantastic recipe I use. But I’m definitely a crust person when it comes to any pie, and this looks like the perfect crust/filling ratio. Thanks for the recipe! And happy almost-Thanksgiving!

  21. Amy says:

    Made this today and it looks and smells wonderful. Seems easier for me than pie to make. I had to cook it for about 55 minutes though. I don’t have trouble with my oven, in fact usually I pull things out a little early. But I wanted to ask if the times were off or perhaps my oven didn’t get hot enough at 350’?

    • Mel says:

      Amy – I made it at the time suggested in the recipe but it’s always a good idea to keep an eye on it like you did. Not sure why you needed the extra time but as long as it bakes through without the crust getting overdone, it should be fine.

  22. Kristen says:

    I made this recipe tonight in preparation for Thanksgiving (too much going on scheduling the next few days…) so I was curious- would you suggest storing it in the fridge or freezer until Thursday? I want to make sure it still will taste fresh and amazing when I serve it. Thanks!

    • Mel says:

      Kristen – hmm, this far in advance, I’d probably freeze it until Wednesday and then take it out and put it in the fridge (I haven’t frozen it before so I’m not exactly sure how it will fare but I think it should be fine). Good luck!

  23. Rebecca says:

    I would love to make this and bring to my in laws for thanksgiving but we are traveling for five hours. I want to make this Wednesday morning but I am wondering will it be ok for the drive or how would you suggest traveling with it? Thanks

  24. Rebecca says:

    Thanks so much Mel for the response. I look forward to making this Wednesday. All of your recipes are always a hit in my house

  25. Andreya says:

    My family loved this recipe! I made it for our annual “pie night” before Thanksgiving and it was a huge success! Your recipes are heaven sent!

  26. Sujoomama says:

    I am making this one for Thanksgiving! It looks soooo delicious!

  27. Amy V says:

    Hi Mel, I just pulled these out of the oven and they look great! I doubled the recipe and used a jelly roll pan (commercial half sheet pan) and there was definitely too much filling, by at least 1.5 cups. I just baked it separately in a ramekin! Yum! I’ll let you know how they turn out!

  28. Lindsay says:

    Can I substitute pumpkin pie spice in this recipe? If so, how much should I use?

    • Mel says:

      Hi Lindsay – the original recipe uses pumpkin pie spice, I believe, so if you follow the link below the recipe I posted it should give a good tip on that. Good luck!

  29. Sheree says:

    Made this for Thanksgiving dinner, and we loved it! We are pumpkin pie fans in this house, so my husband was skeptical about straying from tradition, but I like this even better than regular pumpkin pie (even though I accidentally left out the vanilla in the pie crust). I will definitely be making this again. Thanks, Mel!

  30. Gretchen says:

    I made this for Thanksgiving and it was a HUGE hit. I won’t ever make pumpkin pie again. There is no need. Also I used a bigger jelly roll pan so it was thinner (not on purpose but its all I had). I also just used regular milk (again all I had). This recipe is a winner, winner, winner! Thanks for posting. I mean all your recipes are awesomeness.

  31. Rebecca M says:

    Just wanted to come back and say that I did make this for thanksgiving and it was amazing. I made some changes by adding ground pecans to the crust as well as saving some of the crust and adding it as a crumble on top of the pumpkin along with some chopped pecans. It came out beyond incredible and it traveled perfectly. Thanks again Mel :)

  32. Andrea says:

    I, too, just wanted to come back and say thank you, Mel. This dessert was a big hit at Thanksgiving and one of the only things that we didn’t have leftovers of! By the way, I made it the night before, and it was just fine. :)

  33. Kristen says:

    Update on freezing- I froze it Sunday- weds and served it on thanksgiving and it was great! I think chilling it made it taste even better. I am still enjoying leftovers! Thanks for the recipe and the suggestions! This one is a keeper.

  34. Jamie says:

    I had a leftover can of pumpkin, so I’m making this for dessert tonight. It’s in the oven right now, so fingers crossed. :)

    I have a question about the crust. It seemed slightly runny, with no chance of forming a “cohesive ball”. More like a thick puddle. I added a few tablespoons of flour to thicken it up, and was able to press it into the pan. It didn’t just run, so that seemed pretty good. Hopefully I haven’t messed up the recipe. I guess I will find out when it’s done.

    I’m wondering if anyone has had the same experience? Maybe that’s how the recipe is supposed to be? I’d like to hear from others who have made this about the texture or wetness of the crust.

    • Mel says:

      Hi Jamie – the texture of my crust sounds like it was definitely thicker than yours – able to be pressed into the pan (like a shortbread almost but a little softer than that).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.