French Bread Rolls {Step-by-Step}
These popular, no-fail French bread rolls are light, fluffy and delicious! They are so easy to make; perfect for bread-making beginners and experts alike!
If you want one of the easiest, foolproof, most delicious roll recipes around, this is it.
This French bread roll recipe has been around a loooooong time, and after 10+ years, it is still the roll recipe I probably make the most (that’s saying a lot, because I have a lot of favorite roll recipes).
A Very Forgiving Dough
The dough for these French bread rolls is straightforward and very forgiving. I usually use my Bosch stand mixer, but many of you make this dough in a KitchenAid mixer and others make it by hand.
Dough ingredients:
- warm water
- yeast (instant or active dry yeast)
- sugar
- oil
- salt
- flour (all-purpose or bread flour)
Mix all the ingredients together until the dough forms a soft, slightly sticky ball of dough that clears the sides of the bowl and doesn’t leave a lot of sticky residue on your fingers.
How to Make Yeast Dough at Home
Stop stressing about adding the exact amount of flour called for in a recipe! Many, many factors determine how much flour is needed (elevation, humidity, how we each measure flour, etc.)
Judge the dough based on how it feels and how it looks. If you need to add a bit more flour, that’s ok!
For this recipe, grab a piece of dough after the flour has been added. Initially, it might leave a little sticky residue on your fingers.
Try rolling it into a ball without any oil or cooking spray on your hands. If it can form a ball shape without sticking to your hands in a shaggy, horror-movie mess, you are good to go. If not, add a bit more flour (a couple tablespoons), mix and try again.
Adding too much flour can spell death to light and fluffy homemade bread or rolls.
Let it Rise
I’m lazy and let the dough rise right in the mixing bowl. It is a pretty quick-rising dough.
Once it has doubled in size, it’s ready to get shaped into rolls.
Shape the Rolls
Cut the dough into 12 equal pieces. I usually weigh each piece to make sure they are uniform. Each dough piece usually weighs right around 2.6 to 2.7 ounces.
Cup your hand and roll the dough into a smooth ball (keep the pinky side of your hand against the counter while you roll). Pinch the bottom to seal, if needed.
Place the rolls in a greased 9X13-inch pan.
For a double batch (I almost always double the batch), I like to place and bake the rolls on a half sheet pan (24 rolls fit perfectly).
Bake the rolls until golden and then brush the tops with butter.
The Perfect Roll for Sandwiches or Subs
Over the years, these French bread rolls have become more than a dinner roll.
These French bread rolls have become my go-to for any recipe that needs a wonderful all-purpose roll or bun.
Here are a few examples:
Whole Wheat Version
I also posted a 100% whole wheat version of these French bread rolls with a few small but important notes/changes, so if whole wheat is more your jam, check that out (although you can definitely add whole wheat flour to the recipe below as I’ve done many a time throughout the years).
Freezer Friendly
There is not an easier, more perfect roll recipe out there!
These French bread rolls come together fast, and honestly, I haven’t met a single person who wouldn’t fight to the death for one of these fluffy, heavenly rolls.
I always, always at least double (most often triple) the French bread rolls batch, because the baked and cooled rolls freeze amazingly well!
Step by Step French Bread Rolls
Tools for Making French Bread Rolls at Home:
*Affiliate links included below for products I’ve purchased from Amazon; feel free to shop around for the best price!*
- -I like to weigh out the dough for this recipe and others; this is the beloved kitchen scale that I have
- -Here is the large 8-quart container I use for letting the dough rise (comes in many different sizes; also carried in stores like Standard Restaurant Supply, if you have one local); smaller 4-quart version here (keep in mind you have to purchase the lids separately)
- –Silicone pastry brush for slathering on the butter
- -My favorite OXO bench knife for portioning out the dough
A quick note about mixers: I have a Bosch Universal and use it for 99% of the bread recipes I make. Here is a side-by-side (unsponsored) review I did between a Bosch stand mixer and a KitchenAid stand mixer.
French Bread Rolls
Ingredients
- 1 ½ cups warm water
- 1 tablespoon instant or active dry yeast (see note)
- 2 tablespoons granulated sugar or honey
- 2 tablespoons canola oil, vegetable oil or other neutral-flavored oil (olive oil will work, too)
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 3 ½ to 4 cups (497 to 569 g) all-purpose or bread flour, more or less (see note)
Instructions
- In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the dough hook or in a large bowl by hand, combine the warm water, instant yeast, sugar, oil, salt and 2 cups of the flour.
- Begin mixing, and continue to add the rest of the flour gradually until the dough has pulled away from the sides of the bowl. Begin kneading the dough for 4-5 minutes in a stand mixer (7-9 minutes by hand).
- The dough should be soft and smooth but still slightly tacky to the touch. After a few minutes of kneading, stop the mixer and grab a small piece of dough to test if it needs more flour or not. It might leave a little bit of sticky residue on your fingers, but if you can roll it into a small ball without it sticking all over to your hands, it is good to go. If not, gradually add a bit more flour as needed.
- Place the dough in a lightly greased bowl and cover. Let the dough rise until doubled, 1-2 hours.
- Lightly punch down the dough and turn it out onto a lightly greased countertop.
- Divide the dough into 12 equal pieces (about 2.75 ounces each, more or less), and form the dough into round balls (video tutorial here right at minute marker 2:20).
- Place the rolls in a lightly greased 9X13-inch pan or on a large, rimmed baking sheet lined with parchment or lightly greased. Space the rolls about 1/2- to 1-inch apart.
- Cover the rolls with lightly greased plastic wrap taking care not to pin the plastic wrap under the baking sheet or else the rolls will flatten while rising. Let the plastic wrap gently hang over the sides of the pan to fully cover the rolls but not press them down.
- Let the rolls rise until very puffy and doubled, about 45 minutes to 1 hour.
- Preheat the oven to 400 degrees. Bake for 15-17 minutes until lightly browned and cooked through.
- Immediately out of the oven, brush with butter.
Notes
Recommended Products
Recipe Source: Mel’s Kitchen Cafe
Recipe originally published 12/2007; updated with new pictures, step-by-step tutorial, and recipe notes.
987 Comments on “French Bread Rolls {Step-by-Step}”
Really good and easy.
Great recipe, I found it easy to make and they tasted fabulous. Just found the wait around the rising a little frustrating but that was because we were under the clock to get our little man to bed.
I would love to make these rolls, but my daughter has celiac disease. Has this recipe been tested with 1:1 gluten free flour?
I have not tested it that way – I’m sorry! Generally speaking yeast bread recipes don’t work with a 1:1 flour sub with gluten free flour. It often takes a lot of other adjustments.
No worries at all! I had scrolled through quite a few comments to see if anyone else had tried it but didn’t see anything. Thank you for letting me know!
I love this recipe! My family constantly ask for these buns! But I dont know how to double this recipe
How do I double the recipe? Do I double every ingredient?
Yes, double everything straight across.
Our daughter made these and they are awesome! I will be making these!
Easy to follow and excellent results! I made mine with honey and avocado oil. Very fluffy!
So easy and delicious!! My family loves these rolls and now this is the only recipe I use!! My husband likes to eat them warm. Can I reheat the leftover rolls without losing the softness?
They really are best on the same day, but they can be reheated in a warm oven or for a few seconds in the microwave, if needed.
Where have these rolls been all my life! I just made them and they are absolutely delicious.
We’ve loved these French bread rolls, both as a vehicle for butter and for burger or sandwich buns. One note for bakers – these will be pretty big after shaping and rising, and VERY large after baking. They won’t be small like a store bought Hawaiian roll or dinner roll.
Can I make this and roll them out and put them in the fridge overnight n bake them the next day
Yes, that works great.
Can I use equal amount melted butter for the oil?
I think so!
This recipe was fantastic. It was so easy. Turned out great . I made meat buns ,put the temp at350 for 20 min. .
This recipe is great, easy to follow. Only way I messed up was greasing the tray too much so my rolls ended up with slightly soggy bottoms. Having said that they were edible still and a bit hit with the family.
Just a qick question… Is the oven temperature for a fan assissted oven?
No, it is for a standard oven (not convection).
My three boys were craving cinnamon rolls for breakfast but I didn’t have eggs or butter to make the dough. I searched for a recipe without those two ingredients and found your recipe.
I made nine rolls of the dough. The rolls were gigantic after they’ve risen the second time. I poured about 1/2 cup of warm half & half before baking.
Boys are happy and satisfied. Father approved.
Thank you
These were so easy to make ! I was looking for a dinner roll that didn’t require butter in the dough (as I don’t have much on hand right now). I’m so glad I decided to try these . The dough was easy to work with and rose beautifully. They were easy to shape (most of the time my rolls are weird shaped lol). I did end of blooming my yeast with the warm water and sugar in the mixer for 10 minutes then followed everything to the t. I’m going to brush honey butter on the next batch for a Texas Roadhouse feel !
I would marry these rolls. Soft, delicious. I have to force myself to walk away once they’re out of the oven or I will be tempted to smother butter all over them and eat them all. MAKE THESE ROLLS! You won’t regret it.
Ps: I use them for everything: hamburger buns, sandwiches, dinner rolls. They are so versatile.
One of the top roll recipes in my rotation! So simple and so GOOD!
New to baking and another recipe I tried for my first attempt, didn’t turn out and not very good. Then I found this recipe and they turned out perfect and so delicious. Your instructions were easy to follow. I need a little practice for making the round balls, but so happy with this recipe. Thank you.
OK come on….now I MADE THESE with the SLOW COOKER ROASTED GARLIC BEEF for today’s playoff games and wait Chiefs and Jaguars we need a time out because kick my shoes off fabulous rolls soft, chewy and super yummy with th garlic beef no flags on this play as its a touchdown in our house (Even though I am waiting for my Eagles to fly tonight!). Perfect recipe for both items and thanks for this website I am so happy I found it.
I’m a beginner so tried this recipe. I’m not sure what I did wrong as everything matched the images until the end when I took the bread out of the oven and they were all very hard on the outside and doughy on the inside.
They were likely baked at too high of a temperature or too close to a heating element/convection vent
I am a beginner too and mine look amazing but are heavy to hold and doughy inside as well. My oven has a bread setting which is temp 170c which seemed low compared to the 200c stated. i cooked mine at 185 which i thought was in the middle. Should i have stuck to the 170c of my bread setting after all? Many thanks.
I’m not familiar with celsius temperatures, but if the rolls are heavy and doughy they likely need more rising time before baking and/or a longer baking time.
Yay!! I tried again today, after realising my oven had a dough rising function!! It is set at 20 mins. I used it for 2 x 20 mins for the dough and the same again for the buns before cooking on the bread setting of 170c (338F) for 21 mins and they were fantastic!! Hubby is impressed and i am thrilled! we have just had pulled pork, stuffing and apple buns and they were gorgeous! Thank you for your help and tips.
P.S for UK users i measured the cups at 5oz or 140 grams for the flour and 375 ml for 1 1/2 cups of water.
Is your oven fan assisted or standard electric? For fan assisted, you alsways need to drop the oven temperature by 20 c.
Made these for Christmas dinner this year and they were fantastic!
These buns were a hit at a party I attended last night. I was in a rush so I just added the full 4 cups of flour. I will definitely be making these again. Thank you very much for this recipe!
Haven’t baked buns forever and often have poor results. I followed your recipe exactly (thank you for the step-by-step) and the buns were beautiful, light and tasty!
I’ve made these a couple times since having them at my daughters. Her rolls came out so wonderful. My dough rises fine. But when I divide it into balls and then let them rise they don’t rise taller but spread out. What am I doing wrong? I’ve tried adding more flour and they still came out the same. Any suggestions?
Hi Melinda, you might try adding a bit more flour and/or placing the rolls closer together on the baking sheet.
Great recipe! Thankful for you!
These rolls are the bomb. Your step by step guide made making them so easy. I especially loved the suggestion of how many ounces of dough per roll. I doubled the batch and I’m so glad that I did.
These were very good and actually bigger than i expected. I was surprised that there was more of a “nothing” or “flour” taste than anything. is there something i can do to add more flavor (i did not add butter to the top)
Hi Chris, increase the salt by 1/4 to 1/2 teaspoon – that should help!
I love this recipe, and will make the rolls for T’giving. I always bake immediately after the second rise, when the rolls are shaped, but am wondering if I can leave the dough to rise, refrigerated or on the counter, over night, then bake on T’giving? Thanks,Mel,
Overnight would be too long on the counter, but you could let them rise in the refrigerator overnight and then take them out in time to rise fully (if they haven’t already in the fridge) and then bake.
Making these now to test out for Thanksgiving! Can they be refrigerated the day/night before then bake like your other recipe says?
Yes!
I’ve made this recipe a few times on holidays. Decided to make this for a work potluck. I double the recipe and reduced the individual roll size to 1.5 oz, so they’re ‘lunch rolls’ now! I 2 different combined butters- 1 herb, 1 hot honey cinnamon- to serve!
Question: I made the rolls, the dough was soft after the first rise, shaped beautifully and rose well in the baking pan. Everything looked perfect until baking. I did 15 minutes at 400 degrees and the tops were super pale and rock hard (though the insides stayed soft). I mean, hard like you can’t press it down – it’s like a shell. Is that normal? I tried Googling it to see if it’s just the nature of this type of bread, but everything I’m getting seems to indicate the bread should be soft on the top as well as the insides. Any ideas what could have happened?
Hi Monica, yes, the top should have a crust but still be soft, not rock hard. Usually if the rolls are hard like that they need less flour and/or more rising time.
Have made it 4 times now! So easy to follow. No mixer so knead by hand and always delicious! I used honey. Thank you for sharing my husband and I loved it. Have also made loaves instead of rolls for sandwich slices just as tasty!!!!
Could I do this without a mixer ?
Thanks!
Yes, the dough can be made and kneaded by hand.
These were awesome! They remind me of O’Charley’s’s (wow that’s grammatically correct) rolls! I’m definitely saving this recipe
Can I make these rolls, shape and freeze before second rise and when ready to use un-thaw, let rise and bake?
That should work fine.
Hi! Canadian thanksgiving coming up this Sunday! I was wanting to make the dough Saturday night and then bake them Sunday morning…would that work? Or is it best to just bake them Saturday night and they’ll still be ok for Sunday night?
Sorry for the delay in responding. Did you try this? It should work fine to make the dough the night before.
I had the same question! If you did this, I would love to know how it turned out. Otherwise, I may give it a practice try before Thanksgiving.
Love these rolls so so so much. Making them with your Best Sloppy Joe recipe for dinner tonight– i feel like a dinner rock star!
This worked amazingly!! First time we ever made buns from scratch as we aren’t really bakers In this house. Thank you so much. It really gave my daughter and I confidence to try this again.
I just wanted to say thanks for this lovely recipe. I’ve tried many dinner rolls recipes and each time it would be flat and dry but this recipe makes the best rolls fluffy and soft
Hi there,
Please could I ask you to post the recipe in grams please ?
We have different cup sizes in South Africa and it really is difficult to know if I’ve got the measurements correct.
Thanks so much
Hi I’m from South Africa and the trick I learned is to use the same cup for flour and liquid that way you have the correct measurements. Hope this helps.
I have made this recipe now 4 times and every time I feel surprised: “I made awesome rolls!” I don’t have a machine so I just mix by hand and kneed on the counter until I have a little less than the 4 couples of flour and my dough is smooth and shiny. Love it! Are there other ways to shape the rolls?
You could experiment with other shapes! I haven’t branched out with these rolls since rolling them into balls is so easy.
Hi Mel and friends,
I wondered if I might ask your advice please?
I have been making this recipe by hand for years – it’s wonderful!
But since I got a Kitchenaid last September (to save my wrist which got badly sprained), I haven’t been able to make any decent bread, this recipe included! 🙁
It’s a 4.8 litre Kitchenaid Heavy Duty mixer. The manual says it must be used only on Speed 2 with the dough hook (which seems a bit fast and violent to me), and with any other speed the machine could break, (otherwise I would have tried it out with Speed 1).
I’ve tried all sorts of timings for kneading, anywhere between 2 and 10 minutes. Even kneading in one-minute spurts with short rests to emulate hand-kneading.
But each time it turns out with a very ‘off’ texture. Small holes, like the gluten strands are really short and almost chopped-up-looking. Not fluffy and wispy like homemade, instead chewy and dense.
(Although funnily enough, my grandma commended it – but she likes dense German Abendbrot breads!)
I remembered that you prefer the Bosch for bread – but sadly I can’t get a Bosch Universal where I live! 🙁 .
It has been tempting to conclude that it’s impossible to get good results with my KA – although that would seem a bit odd, seeing as so many people online seem to be using Kitchenaid for bread.
Judging by my internet searches, I seem to be the only one having problems with it…
I wondered if you or any of your readers might have had any experiences like this with the Kitchenaid, or might know where I’m going wrong? May be it’s just a case of “a bad workman blames his tools” 🙂 ?
I would be very grateful for any thoughts?
Thank you!!!
Hi Savanna, I’m sorry about your sprained wrist! And I’m sorry the KitchenAid hasn’t been super easy to figure out with this recipe. I don’t use my KitchenAid for bread making so I don’t have a ton of experience troubleshooting, but it sounds to me like maybe it might be worth trying to slow down the kneading to speed 1? And then knead for 5-6 minutes continuously and see how that goes?
Thanks Mel for your kind reply! 🙂
I think you are probably right about Speed 1. I haven’t tried it yet though (as I can’t afford to take any risks with the ominous ‘engine failure risk’ warning in the manual – the mixer was too expensive, UK sales value £599!!).
Good news is, I have a little kneading helper (my younger sister). I’ve also been trialling different hand-kneading techniques this month with no more sprains 🙂
The KA’s still been in regular use for cookie dough and cakes – just a shame it doesn’t seem to be all it was cacked up to be for kneading.
Apparently the Bosch Universal has been listed on Amazon UK in the past years ago, so I’ll keep my eyes peeled!
Use speed 1! As you said, speed 2 is too fast. I’ve made hundreds of batches of Mels French Bread Rolls using my KitchenAid. I have found for this specific recipe it works better to double it- if there isn’t enough dough the dough hook doesn’t work properly.
This was my first time making this recipe and it was amazing! My family loved it. I will be making this again.
I want to make hamburger buns. How many ounces should my buns be
I use about 3.5 to 4 ounces for hamburger buns.
These are my new go-to recipe for bread rolls! They were SO easy to make and the result was incredibly soft and fluffy! I halved the batch for this first try but I will definitely be doubling it in future batches.
I used a mix of bread and all purpose flour (50/50), and brushed them with olive oil instead of butter as I didn’t have any, and they turned out beautifully.
These are amazing! Ever since I moved to Korea I have struggled with the amount of sugar in their bread. I bought a mini oven a month ago after 1 1/2 years living here so that I could make my own bread. This was my first time tackling yeast and making bread. I just made my second batch. They are perfect! So easy to make and delicious. Thank you for the recipe!
I have a Bosch mixer and whenever I try to add the additional flour, it won’t incorporate it. The dough hook just drags it around and won’t mix it in. Do you have any idea what I’m doing wrong?
Hi Lyndel, try adding all the flour at once instead of gradually; Bosch mixers have a harder time with smaller batches of dough, but adding the flour all at once can often help.
These are so good and easy to make!!
Simple recipe and came out so well and soft
Can I add an egg to this recipe?
You could try! I haven’t tried that so I can’t speak to results.
These are my go to. I’m an experienced bread maker, I’ve tried others, but always come back to yours because they are perfect. Tomorrow, I start working on about 7 dozen for Easter on Sunday. It’s a process, but everyone loves them and it’s worth it!
These are the most delicious bread rolls ever. I also made this recipe into a bread too. One loaf. I am hoping that you could put a bread recipe on. Or do you have one. The rolls were beautiful lovely texture
Mel does have a French bread recipe! https://www.melskitchencafe.com/french-bread/
It’s also delicious and easy! I go back and forth between the two recipes. If I don’t feel like rolling out a bunch of dough balls, then I’ll make the French bread loaves (the recipe makes 2 loaves). Or if I want rolls for “little sandwiches” for school lunches later in the week, I’ll make a double batch (which is what I’m doing later today).
Thank you for such a great recipe, they turned out great, even my youngest 16 year old son who has autism and is very selective (he only normally has seeded bread) tried and liked them. He took a couple to school with peanut butter and jam for lunch today. I’m about to bake the second batch now.
Thanks for absolutely awesome bun recipe. I had to make it two days in a row as it’s such a great hit with the family.
I knotted the dough and I also made garlic butter & coriander buns which turned out absolutely amazing.
Greetings from
Cape Town
South Africa
I have made these buns twice this week. Oh boy are they ever good.
If one overshot the flour can u dribble in a little warm water while kneading?
It kind of depends on how much the dough is over floured, but I’ve done that before if it’s just a tad bit over floured.
These buns are INCREDIBLE! But when I took them out of the oven and put butter on them, the tops lost their smooth finish and got kinda bumpy. Thoughts?
Did the dough form bumps or were the bumps little bubbles from the butter?
These turned out sooo soft, moist and absolutely delicious! I used 2 1/4 tsp of yeast (instead of 1 tbs) and let it rise over a couple of hours. I definitely use this recipe again!!!!
I think I did everything right (texture ended up really nice), but I was left with a somewhat bitter aftertaste. I used all purpose flour (not rancid). Any idea where I might’ve gone wrong?
What brand of flour did you use, James?
when you double or triple the recipe do you double or triple every ingredient exactly as its shown in the original recipe?
If I double, I double everything. If I triple, I triple everything except the yeast (I use the double yeast amount for a triple recipe).
These are the easiest and best dinner rolls I have ever made. I served them at dinner this evening and no one could stop eating them! This will be on frequent repeat in my kitchen…thanks Mel!
I love this recipe!!!!!!
These are phenomenal! I divided the dough into 5 equal parts to use as submarine rolls and otherwise followed the exactly. My family was blown away with the flavor and lightness of these rolls. I highly recommend this recipe!
My daughter in law wanted to start making home made breads, so we started with this recipe. They came out ok. We followed the instructions to the letter and didn’t get a double-the-size rise on the first round, very little on the second. The end bake resulted in a medium-dense crumb, good for a bread bowl if made larger. Not sure what we did wrong, other than we didn’t have a mixer and had to knead by hand. We’ll try again and see how it goes. The recipe is very easy to follow.
I also knead by hand, around 7/8 mins (its a good workout!) and haven’t had an issue. I use warm milk rather than water, same quantity, and mix it with the yeast and leave 10 mins until its gone cloudy and a bit frothy. Came out perfectly hope that helps!
These rolls are wonderful and will become my go-to! So easy and yummy!
These are the best rolls I’ve ever had. Serious. And I was surprised when I got around to baking them myself that it turned out just the same. I found that using a 9×13″ pan with more vertical sides did better than the one with slanted sides which crowded them a bit. My first attempt was with a disposable aluminum pan and I preferred those! Thanks so much for sharing this recipe!!
Another foolproof recipe! Thanks Mel!
Can distal be made in advance and then frozen to use at a later date if so do you freeze before or after the second rise and do you have any thawing instructions
Yes, the dough can be frozen. It’s best to freeze it right after shaping into balls (don’t let them rise first). They can be taken out of the freezer, placed on a baking sheet, covered and let thaw/rise for 6-8 hours until ready to bake.
I have made this recipe twice. First time was for Thanksgiving. They were loved by everyone. Easy and delicious.
I have followed your bread recipes more often than I can count. Delicious! Always turns out amazing. Everyone loves them.
Thank you so much, Dorothy! 🙂
I made the best bread rolls ever today since finding this recipe and the really helpful and clear notes/tips/tutorials.
I felt that my dough was a little sticky at first but I moved it around and it just felt right so I didn’t add any more flour. I put less yeast in by mistake and only 500gms of flour. I covered it with the oiled cling film and left by the wood-burner for 1 hour for first proof then 1 hour for 2nd proof.
I experimented and put some under a damp cloth but they did not rise well. I cooked for a shorter time – 12 mins as I have a fan oven.
They were absolutely fab thank you !!
I am a long-time bread and roll baker. Made these excellent rolls for Thanksgiving. This recipe is a keeper.
Yes, I made this recipe 4-5 times to get the exact process down and to achieve the desired results. The recipe that works for me now is about 490 grams of flour or a bit less to get the dough where I want it. I also baked it a pan with sides so I can get the rise correct. When I baked on a baking sheet they flattened out too much.
I made these to eat with BBQ Pulled Chicken. I’ve made a lot of bread in my life and I think these are great as sandwich buns. I especially love the texture. And, they still tasted fresh after 1 day.
Perfect I enjoyed making the rolls I love the test
Another perfect recipe,Mel! This is the most perfect recipe! I made 4 batches today and every batch came out PERFECT You are the BEST! Thank you for every thing you do❤️
OH MY GOD ITS SO GOOD!!
My family and I love it!!
I was wondering if it’s possible to freeze dough ??
Yes, this dough can be frozen.
For rise,
If I make triple batch ..does it require triple rise?
Just wanted to be sure since it’s first time I’m going to make triple batch
No, it shouldn’t require triple the time to rise. It’ll probably rise in the same amount of time as a single or double batch.
These directions… and rolls were excellent!
Could you please tell me the speed of the mixer in my Kitchen aid? I noticed that it looks fine on speed 1 but if I increase the speed to 2 ou 3 it become watery. Thanks!
If that’s the case, I’d keep it at speed 1.
Stumbled across this when looking for a bread rolls recipe. Impressed by the overwhelmingly positive reviews!
Wondering if the honey/sugar is for yeast activation or flavour? i.e. has this recipe been developed based on American preferences for sweeter bread?
The bread is not sweet at all.
These rolls aren’t sweet – the honey/sugar is used to help the yeast activate, but you can decrease the amount if you’d like.
Making these right now, and they’re done with the 2nd rise. But why are they the size of a jumbo burger bun?! What did I do wrong?
Did they over rise? If they flattened out while rising the second time, it might mean that the dough needs a bit more flour to help hold the structure (the exact amount of flour can really depend on where you live, humidity, elevation, etc).
I just made these and they look and smell fabulous! Thanks for the recipe and this one will definitely go into our regular rotation.
LOVED these. I used bread flour because tgat was all I had. I’m thinking about making the dough into a loaf next time. So good!!
So good! True that anyone can make them. Easy to understand and follow instructions.
Best ever!
Best homemade rolls ever!!!❤️
I’ve had a time making rolls….last time I tried they came out like paste….but these rolls were perfect….light and fluffy with just a little crunch on the top….friends and family ate them up. thank you.
This is a simple, but perfect bread recipe. The rolls are versatile. We’ve used them for fancier sandwiches, hot dog buns, and croutons!
This is by far the best bun recipe I have ever made. I started using this recipe as my Grandson has allergies to dairy and eggs and have found the recipe so easy and delicious that it is my go to recipe now. I have given buns to many of my friends and they all rave about it. Thanks for putting this recipe out there.
I made it today and I can’t believe how good they turned out!! This is very easy to make! I love this recipe! Thank you so much! ❤
I love this recipe! I’m a college student who loves to bake, and honestly it’s kind of hard to keep ingredients on hand I know I won’t use often. This recipe has ingredients I always have in stock and it’s SO easy even my boyfriend (who never cooks or bakes) can handle it. And the rolls? Oh my gosh they taste SO good!! I could honestly eat it all by myself if I had no self control lol.
In which layer i place place the baking try i placed above the hot rod and my bun burnt at the bottom
Put your oven rack in middle of the oven
My first attempt has turned out perfectly. Fabulous recipe. I halved the quantities to test, and made small rolls (1-1.5oz) for mini burgers. Will now make a bigger batch and include bigger rolls for regular sized burgers. This will now be my go-to morning roll recipe.
Hi Mel,
I have a question regarding the yeast. When doubling the recipe how much yeast do you use?
I’ve looked at a few sites and I’m not quite clear on how to measure 3/4 tablespoon and then double. Just wondered what measurement you use.
Thanks so much.
Hi Jan, for a doubled recipe, I use 1 tablespoon or 1 1/2 tablespoons of yeast. Either works.
Can you make these to the point just before cooking an then leave them on the fridge overnight and cook on the morning (for breakfast)
Yes, although they do better to go into the fridge before rising that second time (on the pan). I take them out in time to come to room temp and rise a bit (sometimes they won’t need to rise much, as they’ll rise a bit in the fridge) before baking.
I doubled this recipe for our 4th of July party. They were absolutely delicious and received tons of compliments, even from the little kids. I did adjust the baking temperature to 325°F and baked them for 40 minutes just because they were such big rolls.
These came out perfect! My first absolute success in beginner yeasty adventures. Did a little dance and everything!
Just made them and they were PERFECT! I thought I was going to have some left over to freeze, but they were so good we ate the whole batch!
I made your French Bread Rolls recipe today and they were delicious. I made the rolls a little larger and I used them with Italian sausage patties that my son grilled and they were delicious. Your recipe is a keeper. I just came across your site today and I will be trying some of your recipes. Thank you.
So good. So easy. So delicious. My family loved this recipe and I still can’t believe how easy it was! Thanks Mel!
I really loved this recipe. To be honest every time I have tried in the past something always went wrong, horribly horribly wrong. This is the first time my rolls actually turned out Not just edible but delicious. Thank you for sharing this recipe
I made these yesterday. They are very good and easy to make. I tested them on two of my men neighbors and they loved them ! I was wondering if I used some steam if the crust might be crunchy like French bread is.
Hello! I made this recipe tonight and everything was so we’ll explained and they came out perfect right before I popped them in the oven! My only issue is when I took them out of the oven they were very firm on the top, almost like hard bread. But as soon as I brushed them with butter they softened up a bit. Is this normal? Or am I just doing something wrong
These are fantastic! Beautifully fluffy rolls every time! I’ve used the recipe to make mini garlic butter stuffed dough balls, I’ve substituted half the white flour with wholegrain bread flour, I’ve made them exactly as the recipe and they’ve turned out fantastically every single time! I’ve used olive oil each time in the recipe, which works brilliantly, and I don’t brush them with butter or any other oil at the end of baking because I keep them for lunches for a couple of consecutive days and I suspect they might not keep as well if they’ve been brushed with butter (but happy to be proved wrong if others have experienced differently!)
For other Brits reading – I use 450-500g bread flour, and 350-400ml warm water.
Why is there so much dialogue? Is it possible to just make a few comments about the rolls and get to the recipe. I’m not interested in how long it took you to succeed in bread making. I just want the ingredients!
Give a few tips on baking then get on with it. This is not meant to be rude, I’m just sayin’ it’s about baking!
Mel has helped many people with her helpful , detailed instructions. Your comment was rude and you should have clicked “JUMP TO RECIPE” if you were not interested in perhaps learning something new. Thank you Mel for being you! I extremely appreciate your insights.
There is a button at the top that says “Jump to recipe”. Press that to get to where you want.
Some people like to know they’re not alone when it comes to failures in the kitchen! I can’t tell you how many times I’ve attempted bread or rolls, and failed miserably.
It’s nice to know that someone as accomplished as Mel was once where I am- maybe there’s hope for me!
Hi, I made these today . I cannot believe it how easy to make the dough. I am proofing now for the second round….thanks for the recipe. Have tried many recipes but this one seems easier to handle. So glad I stumbled upon your recipe…..made sausage rolls …
Hahahahaha your comment is ridiculous. God gave you fingers to scroll. SCROLL down to the recipe and YOU get on with it. Holy
It’s a blog… not a cookbook!
I made these rolls to go with dinner a few nights ago and ended up just eating rolls for dinner. Soft, fluffy, delish!
I’ve been making these for many, many years, and it’s still my go-to roll recipe. Today I tried the suggestion from your sourdough post and used 2 cups of starter in the doubled recipe. They came out perfect as always. Thanks for the great idea!
You brilliant thing you! I decided to follow your recipe because it was billed as almost fail-proof and promised rolls in 2:45 hours. I needed something quick that I could start on after my workday. I needed fail-proof because my ingredients weren’t all fresh. I forgot to add sugar at the yeast bubbling stage as well. Oy! But the results, you Grand Wizard of French Rolls, were just as you promised. Thank you, THANK YOU!
As for shedding tears over bread, I stand in solidarity with you sister – I have shed many for my experiments with Indian bread (rotis).
This is a great recipe! Thank you for sharing. My family is watching our sodium intake so I used half the salt and they were very good! I’m making another batch today.
Tried this today and they came out PERFECT so light and fluffy! There was however quite a strong alcohol smell when I was taste testing one before it cooled down, definitely didn’t taste yeasty though. I’m wondering if I could use less yeast next time how much would this affect the mix?
You could definitely try less yeast – just experiment and see how it goes. 🙂
First time I see your recipes and I make this french bread yesterday and had to throw it away., I forgot to leave the yeast to proof. Today I make them again and WOW love them. I am so happy, they are soft and taste so good. Thanks for so great and easy recipe.
Seriously the best bread ever. My family in the past have laughed at my bread making attempts but when I first made these a year or two ago, they thought they were shop bought because they rose so well. Truthfully though, they taste way better than bread from the shop and it’s so much more fun. Needless to say I’ve made them countless times since and I absolutely love the recipe. It makes great loaves and rolls.
Hello, I haven’t made these yet, but I’m attempting them this weekend. I have a big family and would like to double the recipe. How would I double it? Would I just double the ingredients or adjust the salt and yeast? Thank you.
I just double all the ingredients straight across
Awesome recipe thank you!!!
It’s only been 2 weeks since by first batch and I’m making them again!
Made super small (because they rose so much!) Doughballs and arranged them in a wreath around a camembert. Added caramelised onion cooked in 1tbsp of olive oil and rosemary too. Came out perfectly.
I have not tried to make these YET! But I will! You make it look so easy and I love bread! Thank you
Have you ever used this recipe for cinnamon buns? When I use a milk recipe they are always hard and dry in a day or two?
I haven’t, but it’s worth a try! I think it’s actually the sugar in the cinnamon roll dough that tends to dry them out.
I’m bad at baking and I get really sad when it doesn’t turn the way it looks on the recipe, so here’s praying that these really turn out good, for a non baker like me, thank you for the recipe!!
I got as a gift a kitchenaid mixed I have wanted for years, dreaming of making my own bread, needless to say I was about to give up on the whole bread making thing. I kept look for recipes that actually gave step by step or even video to see what I was doing wrong, my dough would not rise or it was too dry, etc. It was a disaster. Then today I came across this recipe. I haven’t even finished I am waiting on the dough to finish rising, but I will tell you that I am super optimistic. My dough is rising!!!!! I am so excited. Thank you for this recipe I feel better now ….
Love making these, perfect every time x
I agree as well that these should be on your best of 2020 list. So perfect for beef dip. And wonderful with all my special holiday dinners. But these will be on the table often now that I know how easy it is to make rolls. Thanks for all your help in the kitchen and again for being such a great writer. Love reading all your descriptions as always! Happy New Year!
Thanks so much Mel, now all I’m thinking about is a roll with ham sandwich , these look so great, headed to the kitchen now..
DCB
Another best ever bun recipe. Thanks Mel. I made 7 big buns as we are having beef dip tonight for supper. My husband ate one and said it was so good. Found my new bun recipe.
STOP reading recipes for dinner rolls. This is the ONE, the absolute, without a doubt best yeast dinner roll ever made. Five stars does not do it justice. It deserves at least 10 stars. Literally, I tossed all my other recipes for dinner rolls. No famous chef, no mother, no grandmother, no school house roll, no restaurant, bistro or diner roll can come close to the great taste, appearance (each one is a work of art on the bread plate) and absolute ease of making that is this recipe. Do yourself a favor and make this recipe. Everyone you serve one of these rolls will be convinced that you have been touched by a miracle.
I have made these rolls so many times now! It has never failed me and is a huge family favourite!
I do have a question now though, I am having trouble finding premade frozen dinner rolls but need some for a recipe, can I freeze the dough between the first and second rise (after rolling it into dough balls)? If I pull the frozen rolls out and leave them on the counter overnight will they still complete their second rise?
For context the recipe I am making is a cinnamon bun bunt pan recipe where you put frozen bread rolls in with cinnamon, butter etc. and leave it overnight to rise then stick it in the oven in the morning to cook.
Yes, you can freeze these rolls…if you freeze them before they rise the 2nd time (shaped as balls) they can be pulled from the freezer and thawed and they’ll rise.
My daughter was amazed, she loved them, rusty on top but light inside full marks:))
Doing them again at the momemt:)
O my goodness, I did it!!!! First time ever in my life that I manage to bake rolls you can actually eat! So soft and fluffy. Usually my rolls are good to go to war with – excellent canon balls. But now if I have to go to war I would be ablw to feed the soldiers
This is an Awesome Recipe! Easy to make and delicious. I make a lot of different types of breads and rolls and this one is a keeper.
This is a great roll recipe Mel! Very simple and very tasty. Will definitely be using again!
Huge hit that my husband was speaking about it even after the whole batch was done
Hi. Would it be possible to please include the measurements in grams also? In New Zealand our cup sizes are different. Thanks
This recipe has a special place in my heart because it was my first successful bread recipe! Can this be modified to an overnight roll recipe?
You can shape the dough and refrigerate overnight to bake the next day.
Made this recipe for thanksgiving and they were a HUGE hit. Omg. The best rolls I’ve ever made. They’re so fluffy and perfectly sweet, but not too sweet. Really loved your instructions, very clear as I’ve had trouble with yeast before. Thank you!
Great recipe! Just wanted to say thank you.
I have made these rolls more times than I can count. I’ve made the dinner rolls, hot dog, and hamburger versions. Turns out everytime without fail. Such an easy recipe!!
Hi Mel, I’m a bread baker and have made your French bread and rolls numerous times; however, EVERY TIME, without fail, I have to add 2-3 cups EXTRA flour to the recipe in order not to have one, big, wet, gloppy mess. It just never comes together without all of the extra flour (KA All Purpose). I live in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia and I can’t imagine that the air here would be THAT much wetter than in Idaho. Could you PLEASE advise as to what the issue might be? The rolls and bread rise and bake just fine, but the flour issue blows me away. Also, you’ve mentioned that you have a flour bin with a handle for fluffing. Could you tell me where you got that? I’ve been looking for one. Thank you so much!
I’m from just shy of the Idaho Boarder in WA and now live on the east coast… the air is very different here vs there. That being said I’m looking forward to making these this week and will take your notes into consideration!
Hi Karen, the flour bin I have I got at Costco almost 10 years ago and unfortunately it’s no longer available. I’ve tried to find them online and I haven’t had any luck! Elevation and humidity can make a huge difference with flour amounts – 2-3 extra cups of flour seems like a lot, but if the texture and taste of the rolls are fine, it must just boil down to the differences in where we each live and how we measure flour. Are you fluffing the flour quite a bit before measuring?
Not fluffing a whole lot (no bin)….ahh…maybe that’s some of the issue…I just made them again and it is a 2+ cup difference, but everyone loves them and they taste wonderful. It’s just that, truly, without the extra flour it would be a totally wet mess sticking to anything and everything. And I usually weigh ingredients and then adjust the flour accordingly; however, with this I spoon the flour into the cup and adjust. So, who knows? As long as the texture and taste are good….I was just curious as to your thoughts. Thank you so much for getting back with me! God bless.
Mel, when just now discussing this flour issue with my husband, he told me that he totally packs down my 50lb KA flour bags in my big buckets. He said in order to fit as much into them as he can he packs..and packs…and packs. Hmmm…..I think maybe this is my issue! Lol! Just the small amount of fluffing I do won’t fluff THAT flour enough! I so wish I could find a flour bin! Happy Thanksgiving!
I saw several comments looking for measurements other than cups, so here is my estimated weights to maybe help out someone. I made this recipe yesterday as a double batch and had a total weight of 1900g which I divided into 80ish g balls. In my opinion, they were slightly too big to be a dinner roll as a side, but would be great for sandwiches. Today I set out to get the weights to leave a comment. The initial weights are easy enough: 426g water, 12 g active dry yeast, 30g sugar or honey, 30g oil, 7g salt for a total of 505g before flour. Knowing my total yesterday was 1900g, I halved that number and subtracted the 505g for everything else and got 445g of flour as my starting point today. I tried that, and the dough was way too wet still (so I’m not sure how that worked out yesterday). I added more and more flour, and then I had flour on my work surface for kneading. In the end, I have a 1135g ball of dough meaning 630g of flour. It’s beautiful, silky dough that’s not too sticky. For 12 rolls they’d be over 90g each which might be great for hamburger buns maybe. Today I’m going to make a loaf and see how it goes. I hope this helps someone. By the way, the rolls yesterday were amazing and fluffy and soooooo good. The hit of Thanksgiving.
I’m sorry, I don’t know why my comment showed up as a reply rather than a regular comment.
To Mel and all of her bread makers: I’m the one who lives in VA and could NOT figure out why in the world this bread recipe, among many others, was requiring me to add 1/3 to 1/2 MORE FLOUR just to get it out of a totally wet state! Well, the mysterious riddle is now SOLVED! YAY!! And I still have hair left! It.Was.The.WATER!! We had moved and, because our water now has chlorine in it (not good for yeast), I started using SPRING WATER. Spring water is soft, leaving the dough so WET that it needed MUCH more flour to even firm up. So we got a water purifying system and Voila’! Back in business! Amazing journey.
I make the French bread regularly and had the same problem, I fixed it by adding slightly less water. Now it is perfect every time. I live on East coast, too. In winter, I can follow the recipe as written without less water. It just depends on weather, kitchen and how moist your house is.
I made these rolls yesterday and I can’t believe how easy they were!!! I added some honey to the melted butter to brush at the end and they were so so delicious!! I also plaited a few which looked pretty but took longer in the oven. Thank you for this fool proof recipe! Xxx
Thank you for the amazing recipe❣️
Hi Mel,
I think someone must have asked this question but I didn’t see it in the comments? Can I make the dough the day before, and then roll it in buns and bake them ?
Thanks Mel !
Hi Linda, yes, this dough does well being made the day before!
How do you store the dough if you make the dough the day before?
You can let the dough slow rise in the refrigerator covered.
I just made these and I followed every step, but the dough didn’t ever rise and I’ve got hard domed mushroom shaped rolls. Not at all how they should be. I checked every ingredient, measurement and detail very thoroughly but I have a disaster on my hands. What could have gone wrong? I had instant yeast, as the recipe states.
Hi Howard, if the dough didn’t rise at all it sounds like it could have been over floured or the yeast you used wasn’t fresh or didn’t activate (too hot of water, or something like that).
Mine didn’t turn out right they went flat during backing 🙁 but taste good
Wow, just made these, little late to the party I’m sure but…
I did have to bake them a little longer, but I’m in the UK, so had to adjust measurements, just over 25 mins. They taste amazing and so fluffy, I mixed butter and honey to glaze on top, my little boy and wife loved them, will be making again, thankyou for this gorgeous recipe!
How can I have this recipe in metrics? I tried to make but I had to keep adding flour as probably online conversions aren’t that good. I read the page and you say that you weight all the ingredients i felt disappointed when I saw it was in cups.
Is there any chance to have all measurements in metric so it will be precise please?
Thank you
There’s no way to give precise measurements for roll and bread dough because the exact amount of flour depends on where you live (sea level, elevation) and climate (humid, rainy, dry). It honestly can make a difference, so I don’t give weight measurements for roll and bread dough recipes – instead I encourage people making them to judge the amount of flour by how the dough looks. My biggest advice to home bread makers is to let go of the idea that there has to be an exact flour amount and judge the dough by look and feel. I wouldn’t rely on online conversions – if you are going to halve the recipe, add flour until the dough clears the sides of the bowl and forms a soft, slightly sticky, but workable ball of dough.
I made the rolls twice ,they are excellent
These are great! I used melted butter instead of oil, and these came out soft and fluffy, with a nice flavor. My housemate cooks and I bake, but we’re uh still working on our timing — when these weren’t ready in time for dinner, I cut off some extra dough and made it into flatbread in a very hot, oiled cast iron pan. Delicious!
I tried this recipe because it looks so good but I think I did somethings wrong though I thought I did it right. I don’t think my bread is cooking I am on 6 minutes left and I see no change HELP!
Looking good but wishing you were metric. US and Imperial ounces and cups are 20% different. A gram is a gram and an ml is the same everywhere. Only the USA and Myanmar use measurements that are not System International, or, metric….
I think it makes sense that given Mel is from America she uses the units most of her country uses!
I am from a metric using country too and sometimes you just need to convert a bit. In many cases though as long as you are familiar with the slight differences between metric cups and the US customary system you can just make the tiny adjustments by eye. To me it’s part of the fun of the internet that we can get recipes from all over the world.
That’s interesting to learn though that the people of Myanmar can make Mel’s American recipes without any extra thinking!
Please will you give ingredients in grams or ounces. I have 3 measuring cups and all weigh differently.
I have made these rolls and they are delicious.
I loved the fact I it was so easy to make. I tried it at home and then made it for a family gathering. Perfect both times.
I was wandering if I could use same recipe for loaf bread?
Yes, I think others have done that with good results!
This is our favorite roll recipe. I make these all the time! This time I added 1 cup of bread flour and I spritzed them with cold water a couple times while baking. It made the inside chewy and outside crusty. SO GOOD.
Turned out perfect! And delicious. And I DID feel like a rock star!!
nice easy very tasty rolls
Made these rolls countless times. I’ve even do a 1.25 times recipe to make a loaf of white bread every week! Beautiful and soft.
I just wanted to say thank you for such an easy and successful recipe.
great recipe!!
made them for dinner tonight and came out perfect The dough was very easy to work with great recipe!!
Seriously perfect bread rolls. I have never baked bread this well before and this is my go to recipe now. Thanks so much!
I made these french breadrolls and they were Wonderful! Many compliments!!
Wow Mel, these rolls and your step-by-step guide made me (a total novice bread-maker) look like an expert when I made these for dinner….you are so talented!! Thank you so much. They are some of the best dinner rolls I’ve ever eaten.
Easily the best bread rolls I’ve ever made!
Happened to need some bread for dinner I made these lovely bread rolls for the first time in my life!! They are perfect – together with the method of rolling them into perfectly round shape! Totally love them!
I am wondering if I need some small crusty rolls, can I use the same recipe, put them further apart on the baking tray, and add hot water into the oven when baking?
Yes, that sounds like a great idea and should work well!
I just made this French Bread Rolls. They turned out really beautiful. Just as you have showed in your presentation. Thank you for sharing.
Thank you so much for this recipe and the included tips! This was the first time I successfully made soft dinner rolls (though I have attempted it many times). They were too delicious, so it looks like I’ll have to make another batch for tomorrow’s planned Philly Cheesesteak Sloppy Joe’s. Oh well. 😉
I made these. They were as promised- perfectly light and fluffy!
hi there – I have made 2 bun recipes – both which failed! Came across yours and hope that it is fool proof! Quick question – if I want to add some cheddar cheese to the tops of the buns – when is the best time to do this? Thanks!
I would probably add it right before baking.
First time bread making in…oh 40??? years!
And it worked!
I wasn’t sure the water/flour amounts was working – it seemed to need FAR more flour…but I am British and I don’t know what a “cup” measurement is…a plastic box in my kitchen says “1 Cup”…but I think it’s too much.
Also – came out very very white…and tasted a bit bland….I need to add something to make it more interesting?
But the texture is a success!!!!
1 cup is equivalent to 8 ounces or 250ml
Hi. I baked the rolls at 400 F for 15 minutes and they were VERY brown and a slightly hard on top and bottom. Any suggestions please. I am w newby baker
Your oven might run hot like mine. I cannot bake rolls at 400. I cooked these at 350 based on previous experience and they came out great.
Hi Natasha, it’s quite possible your oven bakes hotter than mine…so you can try reducing the temperature by 25 degrees or so.
Hello Mel, I wish to make and bake your French Bread Roll Recipe however do I use U.S. or Australian measuring cups? I have both. I am in Australia, which country’s measures are you using? Thank you.
Hi Anna, my recipes are based on US measuring cups
These look amazing! Do you think they Would work for sloppy joes?
Thx so much!!
Yes, they work great for sloppy joes. 🙂
Thankyou so much, you were right. This was my first attempt at rolls and it came out exactly as you said it would. They were perfect and delicious. Cooked without fan, top and bottom element only. Lower shelf. Rolled as you instructed.
These turned out so well! I added cheese, olives and some dried herbs & chilli flakes on top before popping them in the oven (at 190 for 30 mins) and they’re delicious with the perfect texture (soft and fluffy inside with a thin, crispy outside)
Thanks for the recipe!
This recipe is wonderful and I love the soft rolls. For a fun twist I added an egg and used butter instead of oil and they were amazing too! The egg and butter gives a little more flavor.
Oops I meant pretty as yours ha ha
I made this and it taste delish but all my rolls split so they don’t look as pottery as yours????
Did they split on top or on the sides?
Hi. Do you bake it with fan oven on or off? Thanks
I usually use standard bake not convection (with the fan on); if using convection, I’d suggest lowering the temperature by 25 degrees.
Can you make these ahead of time and refrigerate then let sit out before baking?
Do you mean shaping and refrigerating? Yes, you can do that…then just let them rise at room temp before baking (there’s a good chance they’ll rise in the refrigerator a bit, too).
Made them today great
I usually make bread on a Sunday. So I will try your method it was presented very clear. Thank you
These rolls are amazing, thanks for sharing your recipe! I’ve made so many batches now and freeze them.
Just quick question can I double the mixture to do a bigger batch in one go or would you recommend doing individual batches? Thanks 🙂
Very easy and delicious rolls! Nice using instant yeast and not needing to proof or scald milk… I was nervous about adding more than 1/2 cup more flour than the recipe called for, because it’s ‘so easy’ for me to over flour to get away from stickiness. WONDERFUL flavor and texture! The whole family enjoys them, and I will definitely make again & again! Thanks so much. God bless you for sharing & for all your work explaining with pictures!
`
Time & temp wrong. Needs 190 25mins. Otherwise doughy but overcooked on outside at 204c for 15 mins. Look great tho
These came out sooo gorgeous and I haven’t had the best luck with bread making but you were right this did give me hope for future baking now that I know and have proof that I can do it!
Help! I’ve now made two batches of hickey pucks ♀️. First and second rise go well (except first batch the cling wrap stuck to the rolls and when I peeked it off they all flattened. This time, I really greased the cling wrap… they rose well (maybe too well..,.. they grew together) and baked flat again. Teach me your ways!!!!
Hi Michelle, if they rise well but flatten in the oven, it sounds like the rolls may be over rising (and then they expand too much and “pop” like a balloon in the oven).
I never use plastic wrap on my dough rising. I use a damp light weight kitchen towel. It doesn’t cling like the plastic wrap! With plastic wrap I had to many mishaps like you! Plus it’s good for environment!
Oh gosh! Just love it.
Initially I was worried when it became too sticky after risen for an hour. I just spray canola oil on my counter and good to go. Came in good shape.. hehez..
The only thing was it was a bit darker after out from oven. I placed it on 2nd rack in my oven. (5 racks in total) and baked at 185°c.
I will definitely do again. My son loved it!
Do I need to make any adjustments?
Try lowering the temperature or bake for just a few minutes less.
400 degrees?????
200 degrees for uk
These rolls turned out as pictured. I had high hopes for them. I followed the recipe to the letter but they turned out with a very yeasty flavour? They looked the goods but I wouldn’t say they were delicious as everyone else has said. I will try again with hope.
These are the easiest and most delicious rolls I have ever baked make them every week now no need to buy bread anymore make my sandwiches with these.
Thank you for sharing
I have made this recipe several times over the Covid-19 lockdown, and the resulting rolls have been awesome every time. I won’t be buying dinner rolls again. So easy and delicious! Thank you
I made these and I got more than 12 and bigger too. They were soft and fluffy. Very easy to make. I’m keeping this recipe!
Have made these a few times and they are always delicious. I gave the recipe to my son and he makes them now for his family. I am also interested in knowing if I could turn the dough into a loaf pan and bake it? Temp and time? Thanks!
I’m sure you could! I’ve only ever made these as rolls because I have this French bread recipe that I love: https://www.melskitchencafe.com/french-bread/
This is my go to bun recipe, we all love it! Do you think it would work to make into a loaf of bread?
I’ve only ever made these as rolls because I have this French bread recipe that I love: https://www.melskitchencafe.com/french-bread/ but you could definitely experiment!
I didn’t follow the recipe to the letter and put the rolls on a sheet pan spaced apart and I made it a little larger so they ended up like hamburger bun size (by accident) after the final rise. They came out great. I will try and cut the rolls in half to make a sandwichs later this week. Good flavor with a nice chewiness to it. This recipe is a keeper. Thanks a lot.
The best rolls so
Light and fluffy and easy to make.
Girrrlll….these were PERFECTION. From now on, these will be my go-to dinner rolls. Everyone gobbled them right on up!
Hi, Mel! I made these rolls tonight and they were delicious! I made a parmesan, garlic, parsley and butter mixture to put on top, to emulate a kind of garlic knot flavor and it was a great addition! However, I was wondering what the best way to store these is and how long the “shelf life” is for leaving them on the counter. Thanks so much for this recipe – I will be making it often!
Hi Shelby, I store them in a ziploc bag at room temperature. They are good for 1-2 days – after that they get a little dry (but they freeze great, too!)
Hi Mel,
Just wondering, do you think I could substitute all-purpose flour with bread flour, as I am running out of all-purpose. I love this recipe! So delicious and so easy!
yes for sure!
I baked the french bread rolls for the very firat time last evening and Ohhhh lord,they are yummy.
My children are excited.
Thank you Mel for sharing,I thank God for you and the succes I had
This sounds delicious. I will definitely try this recipe.
I made the French bread rolls today after finding your recipe while looking for a French bread recipe (which I also am going to try soon). My family thought the rolls were fabulous and I am going to make more to take to my in-laws once the stay-at-home order is lifted.
Thank you Mel. Trying it for the 1st time. Crossing fingers and toes
Hi, i dont have the cling wrap can I still bake without the cling wrap?
Yes, you can cover them with a clean kitchen towel
Just baked a batch of these today, really good. Made the dough, shaped into 8 larger rolls and placed on baking tray last night, placed in fridge overnight so that I could pop them in the oven this morning ready for lunch. Only used half the sugar and still good.
Thank you for this lovely recipe
I made these for the first time as hamburger buns. I was so happy, they turned out perfectly! They are delicious! Thank you for all the great instructions.
I am intimidated by yeast doughs and prone to overmixing things. This was very easy to follow and execute, all ingredients in hand. The tips were helpful. It was very forgiving of the fact that I kept forgetting about it!
Thanks!
I made these for the first time and it was so easy, and they were the most beautiful rolls ever – only they tasted like cardboard (as my husband said). I can only assume it was my ingredients because they sure looked delicious. The yeast I used was old, although it was active and the dough did rise. But maybe that threw off the flavor. And I used AP Flour versus bread flour. And, I used a low sodium salt. So it could have been all three factors ?? Not sure, but I will definitely try this again if I can get more yeast, and maybe I will try a different flour.
I would love to make this recipe but why people cant use proper metric measurements and resort to cups which seem to be different sizes in different countrys is beyond me
Yes, exactly. Please use a digital set of scales and weigh the ingredients. Australian cups/tablespoons are different but all weight in grams is the same.
Aloha from Hawaii. I have never baked bread before and made these with my wife’s help over video chat today. Thanks for such an easy recipe that makes amazing rolls!
Hi Mel
I’m Sanath from Sri Lanka, For the first time we made very very soft amazing buns by using your recipe. Thanks a million… we were so happy when it was baked so amazingly.. Keep up the good work… Go Bless……
Making these lovely rolls today per my husbands request, it’s his birthday. Approximately how many ounces should they be for hamburger rolls. I’ve done it before but for the life of me can’t remember.
Hi Stacey – I use about 3.5 to 4 ounces per roll if I’m making them into hamburger buns.
Made it! Great recipe, explained well. Thank you.
Perfectly soft rolls! Made them today and so happy with the result. Mine were a little odd sized as I just eyeballed it but they are perfectly cooked and super soft and delicious! I’ve made a lot of different recipe rolls before but was always disappointed in how dense they were. I was sceptical about these because the dough seemed very sticky but they were soft and perfect. Will definitely make again and will pass this recipe along to anyone who asks for a great roll recipe!
You’ve prob answered this but after second rise should I leave rolls in fridge while other pan is cooking? I’m asking cuz I have a countertop oven so I my can bake so many at time.
Yes, you can do that to slow the rise on the 2nd pan.
I have never made bread before and I didn’t have a mixer but they still turned out great! Will definitely make again in the future, and hopefully improve my dough ball rolling skills. Thanks!
Hi Mel, I am Ben from Australia. I made these rolls whilst in isolation and I can honestly tell you that I have been cooking for around 40 years and these are the best rolls I have ever made. Have just made the burger bun version. Thank you so much for your website and stay safe.
Thanks so much, Ben!
Thank you for this wonderful recipe! What a gift to my family … we have several food allergies and this was a great recipe for bread while avoiding milk. My family LOVED it! Thanks for teaching me how to make bread!
Success! I have had so many failures with making bread that I had given up. The only reason I even searched for a recipe today was that I found some instant yeast stored in the fridge about to expire, and the boredom of a Covid-19 lockdown. Who knew it would bring my first successful bread-making attempt! So thank you, Mel!
Hi Mel! I’ve been making these amazing rolls for a few years now. LOVE! Question, can the dough be refrigerated before the first rise? Say, if I wanted to get a head start the night before and make the dough then do 1st and 2nd rise the next morning? Thanks for any tips! 😉
Yes, it does pretty well in the refrigerator (as long as it isn’t left there for days and days). It does best if it’s taken out to come to mostly room temperature – makes it easier to shape the dough into rolls.
Made these for the first time
Wow!! The most amazing rolls EVER…my family commented they were better than shop bought rolls
Will definitely be making these on a regular basis
I e made these a number of times and they work every time – and my kids devour them! I’m just wondering if you have ever made it into a single loaf? Would this work? How would I vary the cooking time/ temp?
I haven’t because I have other bread recipes I love but you could definitely experiment!